Michael Wohlschlaeger and His Six Wives: Timeline of Events

PHOTO: Shirley Seitz died mysteriously four years after marrying Michael Wohlschlaeger.
Family Handout

In a house on Camelot Court, in Loxley, Ala., Michael Wohlschlaeger and Shirley Seitz lived a whirlwind romance. The two met and married in three weeks flat, the fifth marriage for both of them. However, there was no happily-ever-after ending on Camelot Court when Seitz mysteriously died four years into their marriage.

Troubled by the circumstance surrounding her death, Seitz' family embarked on a quest for answers.

"20/20" takes a look at Wohlschlaeger's past marriages, beginning with the death of his fifth wife. Here is the timeline of events.

'Sneaking Suspicions'

PHOTO: Lynn Mary Heimberger and Michael Wohlschlaeger married on Feb. 5, 1972, but she passed away in 1977 after choking on a cough drop.
Family Handout
Wife #1: Lynn Mary Heimberger, 1972-1977

Lynn Mary Heimberger and Michael Wohlschlaeger marry on Feb. 5, 1972, in Missouri but soon moved to Gainesville, Fla., where she was a student at the University of Florida.

On Feb. 11, 1977, Heimberger was rushed to the hospital and later pronounced dead. The autopsy report said she choked on a cough drop.

'Sneaking Suspicions'

PHOTO: Michael Wolschlaeger married for a second time to Paula Lynn Rosser on March 25, 1978, and the two divorced in 1981.
Family Handout
Wife #2: Paula Lynn Rosser, 1978-1981

Wolschlaeger marries for a second time to Paula Lynn Rosser on March 25, 1978. The two later divorce on Jun. 4, 1981.

Rosser has since remarried.

'Sneaking Suspicions'

PHOTO: Michael Wohlschlaeger and Gloria Potts were married on Sep. 20, 1981, but divorced in 1995.
Family Handout
Wife #3: Gloria Potts, 1981-1995

Wohlschlaeger's married his third wife, Gloria Potts, on Sep. 20, 1981. The couple divorced on May 7, 1995.

Shortly after Shirley Seitz's death in 2010, her family contacted Potts to ask her about her own experiences with Wohlschlaeger.

'Sneaking Suspicions'

Michael Wohlschlaeger and Diana Yohn married on Dec. 31, 1996, and the two later divorced in 2005 or 2006.
Getty Images
Wife #4: Diana Yohn

The fourth Mrs. Wohlschlaeger, Diana Yohn, is Shirley Seitz's predecessor. Wohlschlaeger and Yohn married on Dec. 31, 1996.

The couple divorced almost 10 years later before he married Seitz.

'Sneaking Suspicions'

PHOTO: Shirley Seitz died mysteriously four years after marrying Michael Wohlschlaeger.
Family Handout
Wife #5: Shirley Seitz, 2006-2010

Shirley Seitz fell for Wohlschlaeger and fell hard fast. They went from "How do you do," to "I do," in three months, and married on Feb. 11, 2006. But it wasn't so happily ever after.

Four years into the marriage, something is wrong with Seitz. In an audio interview obtained by "20/20," Wohlschlaeger tells investigators Seitz had been ill for weeks, citing food poisoning, thyroid problems and, to cap it off, a stubborn migraine headache.

Fearful that Seitz is getting worse, her mother and brother drive five hours to Loxley, Ala., to check on her. By the time Seitz goes to bed on Sunday, Feb. 28, 2010, her mother sees a vast improvement in her daughter after Seitz took migraine medication.

However, on March 1, 2010, the following Monday morning, Wohlschlaeger finds Seitz unconscious in their bedroom. She is rushed to the hospital but is pronounced dead.

Police investigated for more than a year but no charges were brought -- Wohlschlaeger denied to police that he was responsible for Seitz's death.

'Sneaking Suspicions'

PHOTO: Michael Wohlschlaeger is now married to wife number six, Maggie Wohlschlaeger, and they were married on April 20, 2011.
Wife #6: Maggie Wohlschlaeger, 2011

Wohlschlaeger now lives in Pensacola, Fla., and is married to wife number six, Maggie Wohlschlaeger. According to her Facebook page, the couple was married on April 20, 2011.

Join the Discussion
You are using an outdated version of Internet Explorer. Please click here to upgrade your browser in order to comment.
blog comments powered by Disqus
You Might Also Like...